CM 97/98 – Player Recruitment

Don’t worry, I haven’t been researching analytics websites and coming up with formulas of ‘expected goals per 90 minutes’. This game was made in 1997 anyway, so the stats that you’ve got to work with are basic compared to the latest Football Manager and/or OPTA readouts. Part of what makes this game so great is that it has the perfect balance between complexity and speed. Modern management games are practically a full time job if you want to set your team up properly and buy the right players. Anyway…

Regens

I know I’m not revealing any secrets when I say that, on CM9798, new young players are not randomly generated. When a player retires, he is regenerated in the next season. His name, and some of his stats, will be different, but his ability remains the same.

For example, going back to our first ‘Star of CM9798

gudjonsonheidmar

‘Regens’ are usually much cheaper (and obviously younger), then the original player would have been at his peak, so it’s a cost-effective way of buying guaranteed quality

The best way I’ve found to keep track of which good players might retire, is to search by ‘Based Anywhere’ – ‘Age 30+’ – ‘Sort by Caps’

search

You can then make a list of players you might be interested in, and search for them once the end-of-season updates have run. If they no longer exist then you can search for their replacement by nationality, position and attributes

Attributes

For me, the jury is still out on how much attributes matter. One thing for sure is that the attribute scores are relative, not absolute. So for example, the player with the worst average rating in English football this season is…

plymouth

A ‘Heading’ rating of 17 and a ‘Tacking’ score of 18 obviously doesn’t mean that he is in the top 10-15% in the world for these skills. It simply means that his tackling ability is 6 times better than his dribbling (in other words if the ball is within a yard of his feet, he falls over). All of these scores are relative to his overall ‘Ability’ (a hidden attribute, out of 200)

That being said, I like all my players to have good Determination, and I don’t like scores of 1 or 2 for attributes like Pace, Stamina, Strength, Tackling etc.

From my experience (and this is based purely on observation, not research), important attributes include

Stamina – how quickly a player gets tired during a match

Determination – how a player reacts to being behind in a game

Shooting – Finishing ability

Set Pieces – How good the player is at corners (in combination with passing), and free-kicks (combined with shooting and flair)

Flair – how likely the player is to create a chance out of nothing, or score a spectacular goal

Expiring Contracts

For some reason, the AI managers in this game are supremely relaxed about losing their best players for nothing. In general, they will let every player’s contract expire before they offer a new one. Players’ prices begin to drop in the last year of their contract, so it’s well worth your time keeping an eye on who is coming to the end of their current deal.

Sometimes, the player might not even be one that you need. You can sign them at minimal cost near the end of the season, secure them on a long contract, then put them straight up for sale. Be careful though, if you pick the wrong player, you could end up paying a massive wage over many years for someone who nobody else wants. Exhibit A

shevA

Big Club Release Clauses

These can work for, or against you. When you’re managing a Premier League club, you can basically take your pick of lower-league players. If you’re in Division 3 however, you’re permanently at risk of losing your best players.

The one exploit I’ve found to get round this is as follows. When you sign a player with a big-club release clause, make him available for loan straight away. Big clubs will still be interested in him, but will only approach you with a view to a loan, which you can reject.

Make sure you make them available quickly though. Once a player’s value starts to rise, your board won’t allow you to put them on the loan list, and this can happen

curtis

The one that got away (and at a £700,000 loss in three months!)

Searching for players

So although I take attributes into account when looking for the right player, it’s not the most important thing.

First up, I look at average ratings, these are the best indicator as to how good a player is. Again, they are adjusted for the league, so someone averaging above 7 in Serie A is performing at a much higher level then someone averaging 7 in, say, Denmark

If a player is highly recommended by a scout, that is usually a sign that his potential ability is very high.

Making a Decision

Your final decision should be based on weighing up if they are a regen, their current performance (average rating), the opinion of your scouts, player attributes and of course price. Price includes wages. As I’m finding to my cost at Anderlecht, paying a number of players £20,000+ a week just isn’t sustainable in some leagues.

wages

Give me a team of Dewaele’s any day..

So………That’s a quick overview of how I go about the process of scouting and signing. If anyone has got any other ideas or tips, or if you think I’m talking b****ks (very possible), then start the conversation BTL..

Happy hunting

Advertisements

One thought on “CM 97/98 – Player Recruitment

  1. Yeap, I agree with you. I don’t think player attributes are everything. At least, from my experience, what I understand is that it helps a bit. Hidden attributes are also very important and that sucks. I think it’s important for you to see if the player has a “track record”. If he’s totally unknown, then it will take him longer to perform well. Probably because of that “Ability” you can see in the editor, I guess.

    I’ve been trying to play with “underdogs” and that means I’m acting as one. I don’t try to buy big names (like Bergkamp or Bakayoko); I try to figure how “unknown” players will fit my teams and how they perform once the team has established itself on a good level. One of the things I tend to feel is that your team will perform as good as your worst player in your starting XI. This is just a stupid theory but I’ve created this chart to find a specific note for a player. For instance, a central back in my team needs agression, determination, heading, passing, positioning, stamina, strenght, tackling and some technique. I would not have bought Cris Swailes (the worst in the League). Anyway, I’ll sum them all and divide by the number of attributes I’m using. This creates some bizarre notes and that’s when I try to see what my scouts say, how many games he’s played before and his average ratings on other teams.

    I started trying this with more effort after reading Moneyball, a great book about statistics. It’s funny that I used to do it anyway, way before I’ve heard about the book. And now I’m playing it again because of Leicester and Portuguese Clubs. I’m a Benfica fan and it amazes me how our team is playing this year. Not because it is playing great football but because, like Leicester, we couldn’t expect more than this. I tried to “export” this real life ideas to the games and, to some extent, with interesting results.

    And I think I’ve been ignoring “Adaptability” everytime I play the game. Somehow I feel this is also an important attribute but I also feel like I’m taking this way too seriously! 😀 Congrats for the blog!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s